I needed something to read that was wholly unrelated to any particular project I’m working on. So last week I picked up Michael Lewis’s The Big Short, which I bought at a university bookstore sale about a decade ago and never actually read. (Unfortunately, this describes a large chunk of my library. One of my secondary goals is to start making a dent in my extensive collection of unread books.)
I’ve never read a Michael Lewis book. But there is one cursed Michael Lewis fact that’s carved on the inside of my skull: That his going rate for a piece of writing is $10 a word, a number that makes me, a freelance writer, want to jump off a bridge. (The best I’ve ever managed is probably around $0.50 a word and most of my projects net far less.) Thus, my central question going into The Big Short was: Are each of these words worth $10?
Plenty of the book is fine; some of it even rises to the level of pretty okay. But I need to share this one particular passage that just about broke my brain:
[Steve] Eisman had a curious way of listening; he didn’t so much listen to what you were saying as subcontract to some remote region of his brain the task of deciding whether whatever you were saying was worth listening to, while his mind went off to play on its own. As a result, he never actually heard what you said to him the first time you said it. If his mental subcontractor detected a level of interest in what you had just said, it radioed a signal to the mother ship, which then wheeled around with the most intense focus. “Say that again,” he’d say. And you would! Because now Eisman was so obviously listening to you, and, as he listened so selectively, you felt flattered.
I want to stress that The Big Short is nonfiction and, ostensibly, a work of journalism. But this passage? It’s nonsense. It means nothing. The incoherent mixed metaphor of subcontractors and mother ships is only a small part of the problem. Once you start thinking about how Michael Lewis could possibly come to this conclusion about how Eisman’s mind works, your own mind will begin to unravel. Lewis is writing an elaborate fantasy that he cannot possibly verify using any known methods of journalism.
If you try to parse what’s actually being said here, you’ll realize Lewis is just describing someone who is a bad listener and a terrible conversation partner. Eisman is an dick; that becomes extremely clear in other sections of the book. But Lewis’s whole schtick is to find people who think in unconventional and unexpected ways and succeed because of that. Eisman is a character in the book because he realized, long before most people, that Wall Street’s financial speculation in the subprime mortgage market was going to be an economic disaster. And he made a lot of money from that realization.
But Lewis is so committed to interpreting all of Eisman’s actions through the lens of “unconventional genius” that he contorts what, to most people, would scan as straightforward asshole behavior into another marker of brilliance. “[H]e didn’t so much listen to what you were saying as subcontract to some remote region of his brain the task of deciding whether whatever you were saying was worth listening to.” No! He’s just doesn’t pay attention to other people most of the time because he doesn’t actually care about what they have to say.
I cannot fathom how this book was fact-checked — and given the lax standards of the publishing industry when it comes to fact-checking — it probably wasn’t! For days, I’ve been trying to imagine how a beleaguered fact-checker would even go about verifying this. (“Hello Mr. Eisman, would you say it’s accurate to describe your brain as a series of subcontractors and mother ships?”)
Basically, that passage is so bad and so bizarre that it’s actively interfering with my ability to enjoy other parts of the book that are less bad and less bizarre — because I just keep thinking about it.
Thanks for reading. If you find my writing valuable and want to help me sustain this project, you can support me on Patreon for as little as two (2!!) U.S. dollars a month. Or you could throw me a few bucks on Ko-Fi.
I suggest subscribing to my site’s RSS feed to follow my writing. (Here’s a good guide on how to do that.) To get my blog posts by email, you can sign up here.



